The
death penalty is under attack around the country
following the release of four death row inmates
by outgoing Illinois Governor George Ryan. Yet
death penalty protesters were told today to
expect little change in Indiana.
A
bill that would abolish the death penalty in
Indiana has been filed, but don't look for it to
become law. That was the message to protesters
this afternoon.
About
30 protesters spent an hour outside the
statehouse in what is meant to become a monthly
demonstration. Indiana has executed nine men
since the death penalty was reinstated in 1977.
Currently, 32 men and one woman are currently on
Death Row. The protesters were told that they
are all likely to stay there.
Some
lawmakers pointed to practical matters. "I know
what I can do when I can do it. And I can tell
you that Indiana's not ready to abolish capital
punishment in spite of the drama that was
created by Governor Ryan. You have to understand
the dynamics of this place that if we were to
introduce something like that it would be very
difficult at this time," said Sen. Anita Bowser
(D-Michigan City).
Lobby
groups like Amnesty International criticized the
philosophy behind state-sanctioned executions
and pointed out alternatives. "We'd like them to
stop executions and divert the money and energy
saved into more beneficial areas like violent
crime prevention methods, helping victim's
family members. The death penalty says more
about us as a people and the values we hold than
it does about the convicted murderer on Death
Row. Executions carry an official message:
killing is an appropriate response to killing.
By abolishing executions, our legislature will
announce Hoosiers will no longer allow those who
kill to set the moral tone," said Karen
Burkhart, Amnesty
International.
"I
found out from watching the movie "Roots" that
you need to have a Plan A and a Plan B...Our
Plan A to maybe abolish this policy, this
practice, might be subjugated to Plan B which
would be to call a moratorium," said Rep. Vernon
Smith (D-Gary). Smith said the move was not a
response to what happened in Illinois. "This
issue has been before the legislature for over
six years. Representative Brown carried the
legislation before and I've carried it before."
Smith would like to hold field hearings around
the state in support of a moratorium on the
death penalty.
One
of the major obstacles faced by death penalty
opponents, however, is the fact that Governor
Frank O'Bannon was the author of Indiana's death
penalty stature back when he was in the state
senate.
A
moratorium is not likely unless it can be shown
as it was in Illinois that someone on death row
was wrongly convicted.