 |
|
Eric Zorn
|
Ryan's sincerity hard to
doubt if you do the math
Published January 9,
2003
As Gov. George Ryan's end-of-term
announcement on the fate of Illinois' condemned prisoners grows
closer, I'm receiving more and more letters like this one from
Laurence Nelligan of Naperville.
"I find it fascinating that
Gov. Ryan has been able to hoodwink relatively intelligent people
with his `concern' about the death penalty," he writes. "In reality
it's been a cleverly staged distraction from (extended recitation of
Ryan's alleged misdeeds)." He adds that I'm among those "being
manipulated by Gov. Ryan for the purpose of deflecting the realities
of his corrupt administration."
Well,
maybe. But as one who lacks the vanity to believe that he can see
into others' hearts--a vanity now endemic among Ryan's critics for
whom his insincerity on the issue of capital punishment is an
article of faith--I can only look to the record.
Set the
Wayback Machine for January 2000. Ryan has been in office one year
and is in trouble. There have been 28 indictments and 17 convictions
related to the licenses-for-bribes corruption that took place under
him when he was secretary of state. His former inspector general,
Dean Bauer, is telling reporters that he expects to be indicted
soon. And Ryan is on the losing end of a power struggle with
hard-shell conservative state Senate President James "Pate"
Philip.
A Market Shares Corp. poll taken for the Tribune and
WGN-TV shows that only 43 percent of Republicans--members of Ryan's
own party!--say they have a favorable opinion of him. His favorable
rating in the suburbs, where his 25-point victory margin meant the
difference in his narrow win in the 1998 election, is at a
dispiriting 39 percent.
Hmm. How to shore up support among
his political base? How to win a few friends among prosecutors, who
seem to be closing in on him with grim precision?
Any
political strategist who suggests that Ryan could reverse his
fortunes by crusading against the death penalty will be fired for
incompetence.
Though a 1999 poll taken right after yet
another Death Row inmate was exonerated showed narrow support in
Illinois for a moratorium on executions, 63 percent of respondents
said they still supported capital punishment. A nationwide Gallup
Organization poll in 1999 said support for the death penalty was
most concentrated among middle-income conservative Republicans, once
Ryan's strongest backers, 84 percent of whom said they believed in
executing murderers.
Chicago Mayor Richard Daley and Illinois
Atty. Gen. Jim Ryan, leaders whose allegiance might well prove
advantageous to the governor in any number of areas, are former
county prosecutors who oversaw some of the state's most alarming
miscarriages of capital justice.
Even supposing that Ryan
doesn't care one way or the other about the death penalty, it looks
like the absolutely wrong issue on which to launch a comeback,
persuade the law to go easy on him and get reporters to stop writing
so much about his sleazy past.
And, indeed, after he
announces a moratorium on executions on Jan. 31, 2000, the number of
stories in major area newspapers linking Ryan to scandal, bribery
and corruption is significantly greater in each of the next four
months. By late July the feds have scored nine new indictments and
11 new convictions.
Meanwhile, his popularity continues to
plunge. The percentage of those who view him favorably has fallen by
July to 27 from 38 early in the year, and just 19 percent of voters
tell our pollsters that Ryan deserves a second term. Support for his
moratorium has sunk to 40 percent from 66 percent five months ago
(it has since rebounded to the high 60s).
That Ryan stayed
the course anyway suggests three possibilities. One, he is insane.
Two, he has a political and legal death wish. Or three, he really is
profoundly, morally troubled at the idea of giving the power to kill
to an arbitrary, error-prone system presided over by officials who
can't admit when they're wrong and are stubbornly resistant to
reform.
Never mind what he says or what his supporters and
detractors say. Never mind the promise of international plaudits,
the slough of troubles he will wade into when he leaves office
Monday or the cohort of chortling cronies he will leave behind in
their soft new state jobs.
To see George Ryan's heart on the
death penalty, look at the numbers.
Copyright © 2003, Chicago Tribune